If a map is good or not all depends on the person.
Me personally liccianca is a bad map with a lack of action, it's too easy to make it to the end of the map without doing anything as ct, you enjoy it and I don't, I like to shoot some zombies when I play escape :p

I dont want to make the "new removed map thread" to a spam threadso i post here, but there are many maps with a bad balance but they are still really much fun.
For example ze_licciana.
And i never said that a map should have bugs but a good gameplay is more important.
Thats my point of view.